Robin comes to Manchester

Let’s get this out of the way first: This is Manchester United’s biggest signing since Juan Sebastian Veron in 2001, in terms of form and standing in the global game. Veron came as the crown jewel in a midfield that had won Serie A and Italian cup a year previously. He was one of the best players in the world at the time, and the fee of 28 million pounds was a British record fee. In Robin van Persie, United have bought the best player in the Premiership over the last 18 months, and one of Europe’s best players. Since January 1, 2011, he has scored 48 goals in the league, and racked up 16 assists. His total tally last season was 44 goals in 57 games for club and country, and he appears to have to put his injury prone days well and truly behind him.

It seems like a long time ago now – nearly two years – since Wayne Rooney threatened to leave the club over a ‘lack of ambition’, but the club cannot be accused of that here. Hurt by City’s last gasp title victory, Alex Ferguson has signed van Persie to send a message, to make a statement of intent. The fact that he has signed the captain of a rival club, who have themselves made good signings, makes it even more emphatic.

Having said that, it could still go either way. A decline in form is not out of the realm of possibility, as is a recurrence of injury. Either scenario will make van Persie, at 225,000 pounds per week, an expensive flop.

The real issue concerns how he, Rooney and Shinji Kagawa will fit into the team, as well as giving Nani, Young, Valencia, Welbeck – who just signed a 5 year contract – and Hernandez decent playing time. The Dutchman’s arrival will surely mean a couple of players out of position, or spending extending periods on the bench.

It doesn’t have to be that way. A 3-4-1-2 will allow a partnership between Rooney, Kagawa and van Persie to blossom and give the team constant width, while not necessarily sacrificing defensive stability. Evans, Vidic and Ferdinand should do well in that system, and a fit Carrick and Cleverley can hold their own in midfield, but the lack of star quality in that area continues to be a source of concern.

Such a formation is highly unlikely due to Ferguson’s lack of tactical imagination, and the suspicion grows that the squad will be under-utilised because of it. 4-2-3-1 only has room for one striker, a 4-4-2 leaves out Kagawa, and a 4-3-3 comes closest on paper, but will push one of Rooney or van Persie out wide leading to reduced effectiveness.

There is also the spectre of injury. The situation last season was horrible, and it is either that the back-room staff are incapable of keeping players fit, or they are being overworked in training. My hope is that they have tried to address this on some level, because there is no point assembling a good squad if you won’t have your starting eleven available most times.

Contrary to the prevailing notion, keeping players fit does not arise by chance. Fergie may want to give Mancini a call.

As far as Arsenal is concerned, van Persie’s exit is not as bad as it looks, especially as he has already been replaced. Much of the lament will be more about bruised ego than anything else. As soon as he said he would not renew his contract, there was only one outcome. Wenger’s response was to more or less buy a new strike force, and in Santi Cazorla, Arsenal have signed their best player in at least a decade.

The Spaniard will now be the focus of the side, pulling the strings and providing far more chances than his team mates can squander. The concern remains in the defence, with Thomas Vermaelen and Alex Song seemingly unable to remain at their duty posts for any amount of time. The result was Arsenal’s worst defensive record for more than 10 years. If Wenger can fix this, his team can remain competitive in the title race.

How well United and Arsenal perform in the coming season, after this very significant transfer, will be down to their respective abilities to resolve issues in other areas. Arsenal sold where they didn’t have a deficiency, United bought where they didn’t have one either.


6 thoughts on “Robin comes to Manchester”

  1. Nice write-up.

    First. Let’s forget about 3-4-1-2, Fergie has never been a fan of playing 3 defenders and he’s not about to start.

    I would like to see a Rooney-Van Persie partnership which I believe would work because Van Persie plays as a target man and Rooney in the past few seasons has changed to a midfield-drifting forward (partly due to the lack of a strong attacking midfielder/ playmaker). So my front 2 would be RVP-Waza.

    Center of midfield can be handled by Kagawa-Scholes… Kagawa mainly to assist the 2 forwards and play the playmaker role which we’ve greatly missed. Scholes would just be… well, Scholes. Picking up lose balls and controlling the center with those SatNav passes.

    Nani, Valencia and Young would handle the wings and I believe Fergie would choose the best 2 for every match based on fitness and form.

    Unavoidably, this would lead to Chicharito and Welbeck having less playing time. But hey, we need to do better in Cup competitions than we did last season. So they’ll definitely have their own turn.

    Can’t wait for the season to start.

    1. Thanks for your comment. My main concern is what happens in Europe. Frankly speaking, a 4-4-2 is a non starter for United. Kagawa would be playing way too deep to be very effective. Centre of midfield is not his preferred position. I am very interested in seeing how this works out.

      1. I think in Europe Fergie is going to stick to his current method of playing 4-5-1 in away games and 4-4-2 at home. The tricky bit is the 4-5-1, where I believe Rooney might have to play left wing (like we often saw in Ronaldo days) leaving RVP upfront. We can pack central midfield with Carrick, Scholes and Kagawa if it’s a tough opposition.

        From pre-season games, it’s quite clear that Fergie wants to play Kagawa as a central attacking midfielder. He didn’t disappoint (scoring 2 goals from that position)

  2. Very well stated.

    “Arsenal sold where they didn’t have a deficiency…”

    That’s my best part, if only Arsenal fans would realize this and quit screaming!

  3. This signing is so significant because it lets everybody – fans n opponents know that Utd isnt falling asleep as has been percieved In the past 3 years, and it reiterates that we can still compete n attract the best players, a statement of intent to everyone really, especially barca and city. For me, kagawa will have to/can play on the left in a 4-2-3-1 or 4-2-2-2 formation easy, just like siva does for city(on the right even tho he roams freely) n most AM’s that play in england, its not a problem plus with 3-4-1-2 unlikely to feature in fergi’s plans + the fact that we have chicha n welbeck upfront too, its the only way, let’s face it. And as long as our to CMs dnt venture forward too much they’l provide enough cover to allow kagawa to roam. Against the lesser teams he can also play on CM. One thing we can all agree on though is the good times are back at Utd. I remember not looking forward to the EPL start just last week after losing out on hazard n moura and now I can’t wait till monday!. If we get a good LB we won’t be far away from barca n madrid I tell ya.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s